Fraternization in the Army: AR 600-20

An up-to-date assessment of fraternization policy and best practices for Army personnel

Maintaining order and discipline within the ranks is one of the highest priorities of Army officials and officers. It is the job of an officer to provide fair, impartial, and just treatment to all enlisted service members under his or her charge.

At the same time, building relationships between soldiers is essential for the morale of a unit. And this leaves some officers with a serious problem. What constitutes an affront on Army standards between officers and enlisted soldiers? What are officers allowed to say or do with enlisted soldiers, and what could get him in trouble with his command?

Fraternization is the term used to describe unlawful behavior between an officer and enlisted soldiers. This guide looks into the Army’s policy on fraternization, and provides detailed information on what fraternization is, who it applies to, and what the consequences are if a soldier is found guilty of it.

Under investigation for fraternization? See how our GOMOR rebuttal lawyers handle these cases. Related results: Bilecki Wins Rescission of GOMOR for Special Forces Officer Who Helped Soldier Through Divorce and Bilecki Challenges Conflicting Investigations; Camp Casey Lieutenant’s GOMOR Filed Locally. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Fighting a Fraternization Allegation

That’s why it’s important to consult an attorney right away if you’ve been accused of fraternization. Doing so quickly could save your military career, your freedoms and your future.

Tim Bilecki and Ben Gold examine the messages, duty assignments and history of the relationship before accepting the command’s characterization of it. The questions include what each soldier’s rank and duties were, whether a specific regulation prohibited the relationship, whether an exception applied, and what actually shows partiality, coercion or harm to military discipline. An accusation does not answer those questions.

What Is Fraternization?

When a commissioned or warrant officer of the United States Army interacts with an enlisted soldier, it is expected that the officer maintain a certain etiquette and level of decorum as befits his or her superior rank. For a fraternization conviction under Article 134, the prosecution must prove that a commissioned or warrant officer fraternized with one or more enlisted members on terms of military equality, knew they were enlisted, violated the custom of the officer’s service, and, under the circumstances, prejudiced good order and discipline or engaged in conduct of a nature to bring discredit upon the armed forces.

What the prosecution must prove under Article 134

A commissioned or warrant officer fraternized with one or more enlisted members on terms of military equality

The officer knew they were enlisted

The fraternization violated the custom of the officer’s service

It prejudiced good order and discipline or was of a nature to bring discredit upon the armed forces

Fraternization is a broad offense which includes many different interactions between officers and enlisted service members. Dating, showing favoritism, gambling, and loaning money to enlisted members are just some of the reasons why an officer would be accused of fraternization.

In practice, not all relationships are prohibited by the Army. Far from it. Officers are invited to form bonds with enlisted service members and may even be encouraged to do so to maintain morale. According to the Manual for Courts-Martial:

“Not all contact or association between officers and enlisted persons is an offense. Whether the contact or association in question is an offense depends on the surrounding circumstances. Factors to be considered include whether the conduct has compromised the chain of command, resulted in the appearance of partiality, or otherwise undermined good order, discipline, authority, or morale.”

Factors the Manual for Courts-Martial lists

CHAIN OF COMMAND

Has the conduct compromised it?

PARTIALITY

Has it resulted in the appearance of partiality?

GOOD ORDER

Has it otherwise undermined good order, discipline, authority, or morale?

In other words, circumstances surrounding the relationship play a significant role in whether or not fraternization actually took place. And in many cases, defining a relationship can be a difficult task for the prosecution.

Where Can I Find Information About Fraternization Policy in the Army?

Up-to-date fraternization policy for the Army can be found in the Manual for Courts-Martial as well as the most recent Army Regulation materials.

The Manual for Courts-Martial lists the elements and maximum punishment for fraternization under Article 134. A violation of an applicable Army regulation or lawful order may instead, or also, be alleged under Article 92; the prosecution must prove the offense actually charged.

Information specific to the Army’s relationships policy is in Army Regulation 600-32, Conduct Between Soldiers of Different Grades, particularly paragraphs 2-1 and 2-2.

What Types of Relationships are Off Limits in the Army?

As stated previously, fraternization encompasses a broad set of relationships, actions, and interactions between officers and enlisted service members. Officers should be cognizant of how they pursue individual relationships with subordinates, or how their actions and words might lead to the perception of favoritism and partiality.

AR 600-32 prohibits relationships between soldiers of different grades when they:

  • (1) Compromise, or appear to compromise, the integrity of supervisory authority or the chain of command.
  • (2) Cause actual or perceived partiality or unfairness.
  • (3) Involve, or appear to involve, the improper use of grade or position for personal gain.
  • (4) Are, or are perceived to be, exploitative or coercive in nature.
  • (5) Create an actual or clearly predictable adverse impact on discipline, authority, morale, or the ability of the command to accomplish its mission.

In addition to these impact tests, AR 600-32 generally prohibits the following relationships between officers and enlisted personnel, and between NCOs and junior enlisted soldiers. For this rule, NCOs are corporals through sergeants major or command sergeants major; junior enlisted soldiers are privates through specialists:

Who the AR 600-32 prohibitions cover

OFFICERS AND ENLISTED PERSONNEL

Officers ↔ enlisted

NCOs AND JUNIOR ENLISTED SOLDIERS

Corporals–command sergeants major ↔ privates–specialists

Ongoing business relationships · Dating, shared living accommodations and intimate or sexual relationships · Gambling

  • Ongoing business relationships, with exceptions including landlord/tenant relationships and one-time transactions such as the sale of a car or house.
  • Dating, shared living accommodations other than those directed by operational requirements, and intimate or sexual relationships.
  • Gambling.

The exceptions matter. Marriage is an exception to the dating and living arrangement prohibition, but does not excuse misconduct that occurred before marriage. When a lawful relationship becomes prohibited because one person’s status changes, the regulation generally allows one year from the appointment or change in status to marry or permanently terminate the relationship. Specific exceptions also address relationships arising from civilian employment for USAR personnel, certain civilian associations between Regular Army and USAR members when the USAR member is not on active duty other than annual training, and qualifying existing business relationships between NCOs and junior enlisted soldiers outside the same unit or chain of command. Each exception has conditions; it is not permission to disregard the five impact tests.

Community, religious, family, sporting and unit activities are not categorically prohibited. The ranks, duties, component status and circumstances must be examined under the actual regulation.

The Consequences of Fraternization in the Army

If a soldier is accused of fraternization, he or she may face administrative action, NJP or a court-martial. The appropriate response depends on the conduct and circumstances. For the Article 134 offense of fraternization, the listed maximum punishment is dismissal, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, and confinement for two years. Dismissal applies to commissioned officers, including commissioned warrant officers. A warrant officer who is not commissioned may instead face a dishonorable discharge. Either punitive separation requires a general court-martial. These are maximum authorized punishments, not an automatic sentence. The actual exposure depends on the charged offense, the court-martial’s jurisdiction and the rules applicable to the offense date. A separate Article 92 charge for violating a regulation or order must be assessed under the requirements and punishment for that offense. So taking steps early on to mitigate the risk of a conviction is important.

Sentencing Parameters for Article 134 Fraternization

For a noncapital general court-martial in which every offense of conviction occurred on or after 28 December 2023, Article 134 fraternization falls in Category 1:

OffenseMaximum confinementCategoryApplicable confinement range
Fraternization under Article 1342 years10 to 12 months

Offense maximum vs Category 1 range

Offense maximum
2 years
Category 1 range
0 to 12 months

The two-year offense maximum is separate from that range. A departure requires specific facts and a written factual explanation. The court’s authority, the member’s status and any applicable plea agreement can further limit the sentence. These parameters do not state the punishment for a separate Article 92 offense.

Call 813-669-3500Book your case review