Fraternization in the Coast Guard

An up-to-date assessment of fraternization policy and best practices for Coast Guard personnel

Building rapport and trust between officers and enlisted members is essential to the proper functioning of America’s guardians, the Coast Guard. Respect and communication are the foundations of this proud military institution, and maintaining this foundation is paramount to the organization’s success.

There are however occasions when an officer of the Coast Guard becomes too invested in a particular relationship with one or more enlisted service members. These types of relationships can impair an officer’s judgement and neutrality, and undermine the unit’s ability to trust one another and function together.

Relationships between officers and enlisted which become too familiar have a name in the military: fraternization. Fraternization can have terrible repercussions, which is why it’s essential that officers understand the Coast Guard’s fraternization policy and avoid certain relationships that could destroy their careers.

The Coast Guard’s broader relationship rules also apply to enlisted members, including certain relationships between senior and junior enlisted personnel.

Under investigation for fraternization? See how our court martial defense lawyers and separation board defense lawyers handle these cases. Related results: Bilecki Presents Reporter’s Threats and Officer’s Record; JBLM Investigation Ends Without Charges and Bilecki Represents Reserve Major in Fraternization Investigation; NJP and Retention. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Fighting a Fraternization Allegation

If you’re afraid that a fraternization charge could destroy your military career, then we highly recommend seeking out a professional military defense attorney with a proven record for winning such cases.

Tim Bilecki and Ben Gold examine the messages, assignments, ranks and duties of the people involved, along with the actual nature of the relationship. A cutter assignment, the size of a shore unit, a supervisory role and the members’ grades can change which Coast Guard rule applies. We distinguish a relationship that normally calls for administrative resolution from a criminal allegation, then test the specific charge against the evidence.

What Is Fraternization?

The Military does not consider all relationships formed between service members to be of value to the institution. Certain relationships, according to the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ), actually impair the military’s ability to maintain order and discipline in the ranks. For a fraternization conviction under Article 134, the prosecution must prove that a commissioned or warrant officer fraternized with one or more enlisted members on terms of military equality, knew they were enlisted, violated the custom of the officer’s service, and, under the circumstances, prejudiced good order and discipline or engaged in conduct of a nature to bring discredit upon the armed forces. The Coast Guard’s policy on personal relationships is broader than this criminal offense.

An officer accused of fraternization may not see the threat to his or her position or career right away. He or she may not understand why accusations were made in the first place. Officers interact with enlisted service members all the time, and many of these interactions take place while service members are off duty. Forming bonds makes for a stronger unit. And according to that logic, the charges are probably a big misunderstanding.

Even the perception of bias, such as having a beer with one enlisted service member but not another, could lead to charges of fraternization. The offense considers a broad spectrum of actions and interactions, and lowering your guard just once as an officer may be all it takes to be accused of an unprofessional relationship. The actual conduct, rank relationship and service rule must still be examined; an allegation does not establish every element of a criminal offense.

Where Can I Find Information About Fraternization Policy in the Coast Guard?

Information on fraternization in the military can be found in a handful of places. The two most important for the Coast Guard include the Manual for Courts Martial, and Commandant Instruction Manual, or COMDTINST, of which many publications are available.

The 2024 Manual for Courts-Martial lists fraternization under Article 134 in Part IV, paragraph 101. The rules applicable to the date of the alleged conduct must also be checked.

Coast Guard relationship rules are in chapter 2.A of Discipline and Conduct, COMDTINST M1600.2, incorporating Change 3 dated 22 October 2020. Paragraph 2.A.2 states the relationship rules; paragraph 2.A.4 addresses fraternization.

Where the rules are

2024 MANUAL FOR COURTS-MARTIAL

Part IV, ¶101

Fraternization under Article 134

COMDTINST M1600.2 · CHANGE 3, 22 OCTOBER 2020

Chapter 2.A

2.A.2 relationship rules · 2.A.4 fraternization

Professional vs. Unprofessional Relationships in the Coast Guard

The Coast Guard seeks to maintain a professional work environment, one which “fosters mutual respect among all personnel, and in which decisions affecting personnel, in appearance and actuality, are based on sound leadership principles.”

Professional relationships between officers and enlisted members should be clearly defined, with enlisted members respecting the officer’s requests, and officers remaining impartial and unbiased toward those service members in his or her charge.

A personal relationship fails Coast Guard standards when it:

  • Jeopardizes the members' impartiality,
  • Undermines the respect for authority inherent in a member's rank or position,
  • Results in members improperly using the relationship for personal gain or favor, or
  • Violates a punitive article of the Uniform Code of Military Justice, or
  • Violates any lawful order, regulation or policy regarding inappropriate and prohibited relationships, communications, conduct or contact established by competent military authority.

The Coast Guard distinguishes acceptable personal relationships, unacceptable relationships that normally require administrative resolution, and prohibited relationships that violate the UCMJ.

Three kinds of personal relationships

ACCEPTABLE

Personal relationships that meet service standards

UNACCEPTABLE

Normally require administrative resolution

PROHIBITED

Violate the UCMJ

Non-intimate, non-romantic associations, such as an occasional movie, dinner, concert or recreational activity, can be acceptable when they meet service standards.

Romantic relationships are unacceptable when the members have a supervisor/subordinate relationship, are assigned to the same cutter, are assigned to the same small shore unit with fewer than 60 members, or are a chief petty officer (E-7 through E-9) and a junior enlisted member (E-4 or below). A romantic relationship is also unacceptable when it disrupts the effective conduct of daily business. The cutter and small-unit rules apply regardless of rank, grade or position, including Reservists in an active status whether on or off duty.

Romantic relationships are unacceptable when the members

Have a supervisor/subordinate relationshipAre assigned to the same cutterAre assigned to the same small shore unit (fewer than 60 members)Are a chief petty officer (E-7 to E-9) and a junior enlisted member (E-4 or below)Disrupt the effective conduct of daily business

The punitive prohibitions include sexually intimate behavior aboard a Coast Guard vessel or in a Coast Guard workplace, and romantic relationships outside marriage between commissioned officers and enlisted members. The custom discussed in paragraph 2.A.4 prohibits romantic relationships outside marriage between officers and enlisted members, including members of other military services. Special rules separately govern instructors, students, recruiters and prospective members. A violation of the punitive provision may support an Article 92 charge; the listed Article 134 offense has its own elements.

ARTICLE 92

A violation of the punitive provision may support this charge

ARTICLE 134

The listed fraternization offense · its own elements

The Coast Guard accepts officer/enlisted marriages that occur before the officer receives a commission. A lawful marriage does not create a presumption of misconduct or fraternization. A later marriage does not excuse or mitigate earlier misconduct. Married or closely related members must maintain official respect and decorum on duty or in uniform in public, and must not be assigned in the same chain of command.

The Consequences of Fraternization in the Coast Guard

An accusation of fraternization can put an officer’s position and career at risk. The response may involve counseling, administrative action, NJP or a court-martial, depending on the conduct and the applicable rule. Reassignment is not an entitlement or an automatic cure.

Sentencing for fraternization is no laughing matter. For the Article 134 offense of fraternization, the listed maximum punishment is dismissal, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, and confinement for two years. Dismissal applies to commissioned officers, including commissioned warrant officers. A warrant officer who is not commissioned may instead face a dishonorable discharge. Either punitive separation requires a general court-martial. These are maximum authorized punishments, not an automatic sentence. The actual exposure depends on the charged offense, the court-martial’s jurisdiction and the rules applicable to the offense date. A separate Article 92 charge for violating a regulation or order must be assessed under the requirements and punishment for that offense.

Sentencing Parameters for Article 134 Fraternization

For a noncapital general court-martial in which every offense of conviction occurred on or after 28 December 2023, Article 134 fraternization falls in Category 1:

OffenseMaximum confinementCategoryApplicable confinement range
Fraternization under Article 1342 years10 to 12 months

The two-year offense maximum is separate from that range. A departure requires specific facts and a written factual explanation. The court’s authority, the member’s status and any applicable plea agreement can further limit the sentence. These parameters do not state the punishment for a separate Article 92 offense.

Article 134 fraternization · Category 1

Offense maximum
2 years
Applicable range
0 to 12 months
Call 813-669-3500Book your case review