UCMJ 101: Basic Training
The UCMJ and the court martial process can be treacherous to the untrained and uninitiated. At Bilecki Law Group, we are here to fight for you and to educate service members on the process and what they are facing. This is your UCMJ basic training.
The Bilecki Law Group operates from the perspective of seasoned veterans.
Explore the Court-Martial Process
- What to Expect When You Are Under Investigation
- Preferral Of Charges
- Article 32 Hearing
- Referral Of Charges
- Motions and Litigation
- Military Jury Trials
- Sentencing Hearing
Where Experience Matters Most and Ineptitude Is Inexcusable
Military service members staring down the barrel of a military court martial would spare no expense in their defense if they truly understood what was coming for them. The military justice system is unlike any other jurisdiction in the American legal system. It serves both justice and the military’s need for order and discipline. Those disciplinary pressures can make an accusation feel like a decision already made. You need a guide who can walk you through this perilous process from a position of experience. Ineptitude is inexcusable when your career and freedom are at stake.
In many ways, navigating the military court martial process is much like working your way through a land navigation course. There are specific milestones along the way, and each one matters. In land nav, a small mistake in your azimuth grows more costly the farther you travel. So it is with the court martial process. One mistake early in the process can leave you fighting an avoidable problem by the time you arrive at trial. Experience matters, and you don’t want some boot JAG defending your case for the same reason you don’t want some boot Lieutenant leading you on the land nav course.
Facing an Allegation?
The Bilecki Law Group Court Martial Philosophy
It is our belief that a defense can be lost long before the attorney steps into the courtroom. Waiting until trial to build the case leaves opportunities behind. We don’t fill our clients with false hope. We employ a strategy from day one that is designed to take the fight back to the military justice system. We make sure our client’s defense is investigated and prepared, rather than letting the government’s version go unanswered.
Clients who are willing to fight and hire experienced attorneys give themselves an opportunity to challenge the government’s case. You may very well love serving in the United States Military, but that does not mean you should trust the accusation to resolve itself. Fight like hell for your future.
Understanding the Power Of Your Command In The Process
Commanders retain important responsibilities for investigations, discipline and the disposition of misconduct, but they do not control every prosecution decision. For offenses over which a special trial counsel exercises authority under the UCMJ, that counsel independently controls specified decisions, including whether to refer charges to a special or general court martial, withdraw or dismiss charges, or enter into a plea agreement.
COMMANDERS
Investigations, discipline and disposition of misconduct
Important responsibilities, but not every prosecution decision
SPECIAL TRIAL COUNSEL
Covered offenses, once authority is exercised
Independently controls referral, withdrawal or dismissal, and plea agreements
Your commander may be revered for his leadership and ability to stack bodies in a foreign land when it matters most. That does not necessarily make him a trained lawyer. The command’s interest in order and discipline may affect how it views an allegation. Your defense must address the evidence and the authority of the person making the decision.
When an allegation of misconduct comes before a commander, the following actions may be available within that commander’s lawful authority:
Take No Action
This can be the best result for an accused. A commander may feel pressure to appear hard on crime and protective of military discipline. Bringing an experienced attorney in early gives you an opportunity to show why the evidence does not support further action. Your attorney can present weaknesses in the allegations and evidence the investigation overlooked.
In some cases, where even the commander questions whether charges are justified, presenting the evidence of your own investigation can help explain why the case should go no further. Presenting a strong case to your commander takes tact and consideration. Avoiding a court martial does not necessarily resolve a threatened administrative separation. Your lawyer needs to address both risks.
Nonpunitive Administrative Action
It’s a bit of a misnomer to call it nonpunitive when running you out of the military and ending your career through administrative means feels plenty punitive. Yet counseling, reprimands and administrative separation are distinct from criminal punishment. The key is drafting an effective rebuttal that addresses the actual allegations and the relief available under your service’s rules. Depending on the action, that may mean seeking withdrawal, a favorable filing decision, or retention. An option for temporary filing does not apply to every service or every action. Once again, you must tread carefully here, and inexperience in drafting those rebuttals could prove costly.
Nonjudicial Punishment
Whether you call it an Article 15, Captain’s Mast, or NJP, nonjudicial punishment is a commander’s ability to address minor offenses without a formal court martial. That does not mean the allegation is true or that you should simply accept it. If you have not taken the proper steps to fight up until now, you may enter the process without the evidence and preparation needed to answer the command’s case.
There are tactics an experienced attorney can use to challenge the evidence and present your side. The applicable standard of proof and procedures depend on the service’s rules. Do not assume a universal “51 percent” standard. A member generally may demand trial by court martial instead of accepting NJP, but that right does not apply to a member attached to or embarked in a vessel. The choice, where available, belongs to you after informed advice about the evidence and consequences. Demanding trial is not automatically the best move.
Court-Martial
If charges have been preferred against you, you have been formally accused of an offense. Referral is the separate decision that sends charges to a particular court martial. It may very well be that this is what your command intended all along. Your attorney should evaluate every reasonable opportunity to influence the authority responsible for the case. There are also times when contesting a charge at court martial is the right choice. An experienced defense attorney explains the options and recommends a strategy; decisions the law reserves to you remain yours. Getting those decisions wrong could cost you your career, retirement, and freedom.
Three Types of Court Martial
Once charges have been preferred, referral by the authority responsible for the case determines which type of court martial will hear them. There are three types: summary, special and general court martial.
| Summary | “Short Martial” | Special | General | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who decides | One commissioned officer | Military judge alone | Military judge; ordinarily four members | — |
| Criminal conviction? | No | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Confinement limit | — | Six months | One year | The lawful maximum for each offense |
| Punitive discharge | — | None | Bad conduct may be available | — |
Summary Court-Martial
A summary court martial is conducted by one commissioned officer and is a noncriminal forum. A finding of guilty is not a criminal conviction. An accused may object to trial by summary court martial, in which case the charges may be referred to a special or general court martial.
The “Short Martial”
This is a special court martial referred for trial by a military judge alone under Article 16(c)(2)(A). A guilty finding is a criminal conviction. You do not have a right to trial by a panel in this type of proceeding, so your attorney has to understand that the judge is the audience deciding guilt. Experienced military attorneys adjust their approach to the evidence and legal issues. The court cannot impose more than six months of confinement, forfeiture of more than two-thirds pay per month for six months, or any punitive discharge.
Special Court-Martial
A special court martial with members is presided over by a military judge and ordinarily has a panel of four service members. The accused may instead request trial by military judge alone, subject to the judge’s approval. A finding of guilty by members ordinarily requires at least three-fourths concurrence, rather than unanimity. The ordinary special court martial limits include one year of confinement, three months of hard labor without confinement, and forfeiture of two-thirds pay per month for one year. A bad conduct discharge may be available, but a dishonorable discharge or dismissal cannot be imposed. The lower limits described above apply to the special court martial referred directly for trial by military judge alone.
General Court-Martial
This is the most serious type of court martial, and if you find yourself here without proper legal counsel, you are in for a very bad day. Before charges are referred to a general court martial, an Article 32 preliminary hearing ordinarily addresses probable cause and other required issues. The hearing may be omitted if the accused submits a written waiver and the responsible convening authority or special trial counsel determines that a hearing is not required. The hearing can provide an opportunity to challenge the case or argue for another disposition. In other cases, a carefully considered waiver serves the defense strategy. Your lawyer needs to explain that choice. Once the charge is referred for court martial, it’s game on for your life.
At a general court martial, the lawful maximum for each offense remains an outer limit. The sentencing parameters, any mandatory punishment, the treatment of multiple offenses, and any plea agreement must also be considered. The prosecution may seek a severe sentence, so you need a strategy that addresses both the offenses charged and the sentencing rules that apply.
For noncapital general and special courts martial, the sentencing parameter system applies when every offense of conviction occurred on or after 28 December 2023. The military judge must use the applicable confinement range unless specific facts justify a departure, explained in a written statement. The offense maximum, the forum’s limits, and any binding plea agreement still matter. A category range is not a prediction of your sentence. For offenses assigned sentencing criteria instead of a category, the judge must consider those criteria.
This is just the basics of the UCMJ and the court martial process. Building a defense requires much more advanced tactics, techniques, and procedures. If you have a little fight in you, reach out to us or head over to our Court Martial Defense page and see how we fight.
