Fraternization in the Navy: OPNAVINST 5370.2

An up-to-date assessment of fraternization policy and best practices for Navy personnel

Service members of the Navy are trained from day one to show deference to the chain of command and respect their officers. Officers, meanwhile, learn the importance of communication and building trust between enlisted sailors and themselves.

The Navy’s fraternization policy applies to officers and enlisted sailors. It covers improper officer/enlisted relationships and certain relationships between enlisted members, including unduly familiar relationships between chief petty officers and junior sailors in the same command. Both members can be held accountable. The listed Article 134 fraternization offense applies to commissioned or warrant officers; enlisted sailors may face allegations under Article 92 for violating the Navy’s general orders.

COMMISSIONED OR WARRANT OFFICERS

The listed Article 134 fraternization offense

ENLISTED SAILORS

May face allegations under Article 92 for violating the Navy’s general orders

But not all interactions between officers and enlisted sailors are beneficial to that respect and trust which are so important to good order in the Navy. When officers become too familiar with enlisted sailors, or they begin to treat some sailors differently than others, it may create dissension in the ranks, leading to anger, frustration, and distrust.

Certain types of interactions may seem positive at the time, but the military’s code of conduct sees things differently. When an officer becomes too familiar with an enlisted service member, he or she may be charged with fraternization, an offense which could severely impact that officer’s future.

We’ll review the Navy’s fraternization policy in this article to help sailors determine what types of relationships are allowed, and which could land you in hot water.

Under investigation for fraternization? See how our court martial defense lawyers and separation board defense lawyers handle these cases. Related result: Bilecki Presents USS Port Royal Sailor’s Service at Separation Board; General Discharge. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Fighting a Fraternization Allegation

Any accusation of fraternization is serious, and the worst case scenario is not an option. It’s for this reason that we recommend a full review of your case by an experienced military defense attorney, no matter how certain you are of success in court.

Tim Bilecki and Ben Gold examine the communications, rank and assignments of everyone involved, the history of the relationship, and the rule the command says was violated. Whether the sailors were in the same command, whether anyone supervised the other, and whether a relationship existed before a change in status can matter. We also separate evidence of favoritism or a compromised chain of command from an assumption based on friendship alone.

What Is Fraternization?

For a fraternization conviction under Article 134, the prosecution must prove that a commissioned or warrant officer fraternized with one or more enlisted members on terms of military equality, knew they were enlisted, violated the custom of the officer’s service, and, under the circumstances, prejudiced good order and discipline or engaged in conduct of a nature to bring discredit upon the armed forces.

The topic of fraternization receives a great deal of attention because of how broad the offense is and how much damage it can do to an officer’s reputation and career.

Accusations of fraternization may result from any number of actions or statements made by the officer. Gambling, dating, or starting a business with an enlisted member can raise serious questions under Navy policy. Whether the conduct proves the charged offense requires a review of the applicable rule and the actual circumstances.

Where Can I Find Information About Fraternization Policy in the Navy?

The Manual for Courts-Martial lists fraternization under Article 134 of the UCMJ. Its elements must be proved for a conviction under that offense.

In addition to Article 134, further details about the Navy’s particular fraternization policy can be found in the most recent OPNAV Instructions released by the Office of the Chief of Naval Operations.

The 2024 Manual for Courts-Martial, Part IV, paragraph 101, contains the fraternization offense. The rules applicable to the date of the alleged conduct must also be checked.

Navy policy is in OPNAVINST 5370.2E, Navy Fraternization Policy, dated 4 November 2020. That instruction and Navy Regulations article 1165 are general orders; an alleged violation may be charged under Article 92 of the UCMJ.

Where the rules are

2024 MANUAL FOR COURTS-MARTIAL

Part IV, ¶101

The fraternization offense

OPNAVINST 5370.2E · 4 NOVEMBER 2020

Navy policy

A general order · Article 92

NAVY REGULATIONS

Article 1165

A general order · Article 92

Defining Unprofessional Relationships in the Navy

Navy policy prohibits personal relationships between officers and enlisted members that are unduly familiar and do not respect differences in rank and grade. It also prohibits unduly familiar relationships between chief petty officers (E-7 through E-9) and junior personnel (E-1 through E-6) in the same command.

Same command

CHIEF PETTY OFFICERS

E-7 to E-9

JUNIOR PERSONNEL

E-1 to E-6

Unduly familiar relationships between officers, or between enlisted members, are prohibited when they prejudice good order and discipline or are of a nature to bring discredit on the Navy. The policy also addresses instructors and students, recruiters and prospective recruits, and relationships across service lines, including foreign armed forces. A direct supervisory relationship is not required for the officer/enlisted prohibition.

Marriage does not excuse prior fraternization. The instruction does recognize a continuing relationship when clear and convincing evidence shows it existed before a change in status and it was disclosed to the chain of command before that change. Qualifying existing relationships that were not disclosed must be disclosed as soon as reasonably practicable. Disclosure is required so the command can ensure the members are not assigned to the same unit. Both members must preserve proper military decorum and, consistent with sea and shore rotation policy and service needs, should not be assigned to the same chain of command.

Going further, we find the OPNAV describing certain outcomes of personal relationships which could limit the Navy’s good order and discipline. These outcomes, according to the Navy, may:

  • Call into question a senior's objectivity;
  • Result in actual or apparent preferential treatment;
  • Undermine the authority of a senior; or
  • Compromise the chain of command

The Navy does not prohibit all social contact. Appropriate command events, sports and team activities can build morale. Officer/enlisted dating, sexual relationships, shared living accommodations, gambling, borrowing money and private business relationships are prohibited by the instruction. Frequent exclusive social contact may also become unduly familiar; an occasional group event does not by itself establish that the relationship is prohibited.

CAN BUILD MORALE

Appropriate command eventsSportsTeam activities

PROHIBITED BY THE INSTRUCTION · OFFICER/ENLISTED

DatingSexual relationshipsShared living accommodationsGamblingBorrowing moneyPrivate business relationships

The Consequences of Fraternization in the Navy

OPNAVINST 5370.2E directs commands to take appropriate administrative and disciplinary action to correct prohibited relationships. Both members have responsibility to comply; the senior member has primary responsibility for preventing and ending an inappropriate relationship.

For the Article 134 offense of fraternization, the listed maximum punishment is dismissal, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, and confinement for two years. Dismissal applies to commissioned officers, including commissioned warrant officers. A warrant officer who is not commissioned may instead face a dishonorable discharge. Either punitive separation requires a general court-martial. These are maximum authorized punishments, not an automatic sentence. The actual exposure depends on the charged offense, the court-martial’s jurisdiction and the rules applicable to the offense date. A separate Article 92 charge for violating a regulation or order must be assessed under the requirements and punishment for that offense.

Sentencing Parameters for Article 134 Fraternization

For a noncapital general court-martial in which every offense of conviction occurred on or after 28 December 2023, Article 134 fraternization falls in Category 1:

OffenseMaximum confinementCategoryApplicable confinement range
Fraternization under Article 1342 years10 to 12 months

The two-year offense maximum is separate from that range. A departure requires specific facts and a written factual explanation. The court’s authority, the member’s status and any applicable plea agreement can further limit the sentence. These parameters do not state the punishment for a separate Article 92 offense.

Article 134 fraternization · Category 1

Offense maximum
2 years
Applicable range
0 to 12 months
Call 813-669-3500Book your case review