Insubordination in the Military: What the UCMJ Actually Charges

The UCMJ has no single crime called insubordination. The word covers several offenses in Articles 89 through 92. Which one is charged depends on who the superior is, what was said or done, and whether the person was carrying out official duties at the time.
That difference matters. Each article has its own elements, and a charge that names the wrong article, the wrong superior or the wrong conduct gives the defense something to attack.
The four articles
| Article | Conduct | Toward whom |
|---|---|---|
| 89(a) | Behaving with disrespect | Your superior commissioned officer |
| 89(b) | Striking, drawing or lifting up a weapon, or offering violence, while the officer is in the execution of office | Your superior commissioned officer |
| 90 | Willfully disobeying a lawful command | Your superior commissioned officer |
| 91 | Striking or assaulting, willfully disobeying a lawful order, or treating with contempt or disrespect in language or deportment | A warrant officer, noncommissioned officer or petty officer (charged against warrant officers and enlisted members) |
| 92 | Violating a lawful general order or regulation, failing to obey another lawful order you knew about and had a duty to obey, or dereliction of duty | Anyone who issues a lawful order, or a general order or regulation |
Sources: Article 89, Article 90, Article 91, Article 92.
What the government has to prove
The words of each article set the fights in an insubordination case.
- Was the order lawful? Articles 90, 91 and 92 punish disobeying a lawful order. Lawfulness is part of what the government must prove.
- Was the disobedience willful? Articles 90 and 91 require willful disobedience. Failing to obey under Article 92 is a separate offense with different elements.
- Did you know about the order? Article 92(2) requires knowledge of the order and a duty to obey it.
- Was the superior in the execution of office? Assault under Article 89(b), and assault and disrespect under Article 91, require that the superior was carrying out official duties at the time.
- Was the person really your superior? Articles 89 and 90 apply to your superior commissioned officer. Conduct toward an NCO is charged under Article 91 instead.
Punishment
Articles 89(b) and 90 allow death if the offense is committed in time of war. At any other time, the court martial may impose any punishment other than death. (Article 89, Article 90) For the other offenses, the punishment is what a court martial directs, within limits set by the President.
When every offense in the case was committed after 27 December 2023, the military judge, not the members, sets the sentence in a noncapital case. (Article 53)
Many insubordination cases never reach a court martial. They end in counseling, a reprimand or nonjudicial punishment. Those outcomes still follow a career, so the facts are worth getting right from the start.
How Bilecki Law Group helps
Military defense is all we do. Tim Bilecki has taken more than 250 courts martial to verdict, and the firm has represented more than 500 clients. In an insubordination case, the defense often turns on the order itself: who gave it, whether it was lawful, and what the service member actually knew. Call 813-669-3500 or contact the firm for a confidential consultation.
Frequently asked questions
Is insubordination a crime in the military?
Not by that name. The conduct is charged under Articles 89, 90, 91 or 92 of the UCMJ, depending on the superior and the conduct.
Can I be charged for being disrespectful to an NCO?
Yes. Article 91 covers contempt or disrespect in language or deportment toward a warrant officer, noncommissioned officer or petty officer while that person is in the execution of office.
What is the difference between Article 90 and Article 92?
Article 90 punishes willfully disobeying a lawful command of your superior commissioned officer. Article 92 covers general orders and regulations, other lawful orders you knew about and had a duty to obey, and dereliction of duty.
