Let me paint you a picture. You’re newly stationed in Korea on unaccompanied orders. You’ve gone through the brutal slog of in-processing briefings, where a civilian or fellow service member walks up and down the aisles, handing out forms like candy on Halloween. They get to the start/stop form for your Basic Allowance for Housing (BAH), and they say, “Just list where your family is living or where they’ll be living soon.”
Seems simple, right? You’re not trying to game the system; you’re just following directions. Maybe your family was supposed to move to New York, but plans fell through. Maybe the house didn’t sell, or maybe life got in the way. Either way, you list the New York address because that’s what the person in the briefing told you to do. You think, “Well, finance told me it’s fine, so it must be fine.”
Let me stop you right there.
That mindset—overconfidence in the system—is where things start to go wrong. Fast forward a year, and that “simple” form has spiraled into a felony-level larceny case. Now you’re sitting in my office, wondering how you went from a slightly inaccurate form to a court-martial. Spoiler alert: Overconfidence was your downfall.
Why Overconfidence is the Kiss of Death
Here’s the hard truth: Overconfidence can be your undoing in a BAH fraud case. Too often, service members believe the system will protect them because they were just following guidance. But let me tell you something—when the investigators show up, “finance told me to do it” is not a defense. The burden is on you, as the service member, to ensure the information on your forms is accurate. If it’s not, that’s on you—not the person who handed you the form in the briefing.
Let me give you an example. Imagine you’re at Camp Humphreys, and during in-processing, you list New York as your family’s address because you thought they’d be moving there. But a month later, plans change, and they stay at your old duty station. You don’t update the form because you’re busy settling into your new role. Meanwhile, the overpayments keep rolling in—an extra $2,000 or $3,000 a month, month after month. You might not even notice, or maybe you chalk it up to a clerical error. Either way, you get used to the money.
Fast forward 12 months, and now you’re facing a $36,000 overpayment. What started as a mistake you could’ve fixed with a quick update has snowballed into a full-blown criminal investigation. You’re sitting across from me, asking, “How did it get this bad?”
Overconfidence. That’s how.
Don’t Get Used to the Money
One of the most dangerous things you can do is get comfortable with overpayments. It’s easy to fall into the trap of thinking, “Well, if the money’s coming in, it must be right.” Maybe you even start living a little larger—buying those extra rounds of soju kettles at the ville or upgrading to a nicer car. Let me be blunt: That extra money feels great until you realize it’s not yours. And let me tell you, they don’t serve soju kettles in confinement.
Getting used to money you’re not entitled to is a slippery slope. It makes you hesitant to fix the problem because you don’t want to lose the cash flow. But here’s the deal: If you know you’re not entitled to the money, you need to correct it immediately. Every month you let it slide is another month you’re digging yourself deeper into a hole. What could’ve been a simple administrative correction turns into felony-level larceny. And trust me, you don’t want to explain that to a court-martial panel.
The Myth of “Just Following Orders”
Let’s tackle another dangerous mindset: thinking that following finance guidance absolves you of responsibility. I’ve heard it a hundred times: “But Tim, the person in the briefing told me to list where my family was going to live.” Here’s the problem: That person isn’t going to testify in your defense. You’re not going to find them a year later, and even if you could, their testimony won’t hold water. The start/stop form is clear—it asks where your family is *currently* living, not where they might live in the future.
As a service member, you’re the one signing the form. Your signature is a statement of accuracy, and if the information isn’t correct, that’s on you. Ignorance isn’t a defense. Neither is overconfidence in the system.
How to Avoid the Overconfidence Trap
So, how do you avoid falling into this trap? It starts with vigilance. Here are some practical steps to keep yourself out of trouble:
- Understand the Form: Before you fill out your start/stop form, read it carefully. It’s asking for your family’s current address—not their future address, not a temporary address, and definitely not an aspirational address.
- Update Immediately: If your family’s plans change, update the form as soon as possible. Don’t wait until the next pay cycle or assume it’ll sort itself out. The longer you wait, the worse it gets.
- Double-Check Guidance: Just because someone in a briefing told you to do something doesn’t mean it’s correct. Cross-check their advice with the actual regulations. If you’re unsure, ask for clarification.
- Don’t Get Comfortable: If you notice extra money in your paycheck, don’t ignore it. Investigate the cause and address it. It’s better to fix an overpayment early than to let it grow into a criminal case.
- Consult an Attorney: If you’re already in hot water or suspect you might be, call an attorney immediately. Don’t try to fix it on your own, and definitely don’t start talking to investigators without legal counsel.
Final Thoughts
Overconfidence is a silent killer in BAH fraud cases. It lulls you into a false sense of security, making you think the system will protect you. But here’s the truth: The system isn’t there to protect you. It’s there to hold you accountable. If you don’t take responsibility for your forms and your entitlements, no one else will.
The good news? You can avoid all of this with a little vigilance and a lot of honesty. Don’t assume the system will work itself out. Don’t get used to money that isn’t yours. And don’t wait until it’s too late to make corrections. Protect yourself, your career, and your future by staying sharp and staying honest.
And if you ever find yourself in trouble, you know who to call.
Defending Service Members Globally
Wherever Duty Calls, Our Defense Follows
