Sexual Assault / Rape by Force

Case Results 

  • Reduced Charges

Location

  • Fort Irwin, CA

Branch of Military and Rank 

  • Army
  • E-8

Charges:

This case serves as an ominous example of why law enforcement (CID or NCIS) should not be trusted and no statement ever provided to them.

A Soldier was charged with a sexual assault that occurred in Iraq several years prior and was brought to light after the alleged victim changed her report from unrestricted to restrict.

Believing it was in his best interest, and without the benefit of legal counsel, the E-8 submitted to a law enforcement interrogation where for hours he maintained his innocence. Not accepting his story, and assuming he was lying, CID offered the Soldier a polygraph.

The accused Soldier took the polygraph test, and while the results were inconclusive, CID blatantly lied to the Soldier, saying he failed the polygraph. After six hours of interrogation and being told over and over that his situation was hopeless because “machines don’t lie,” the Soldier admitted to the alleged sexual assault. Following the admission, CID closed the case, and the accused Soldier was prosecuted.

The accused Soldier retained Mr. Bilecki after the Article 32 hearing and faced an uphill battle given his admissions to CID. At trial, the defense attempted to show that the alleged victim was utilizing the court-martial system in order to substantiate her retirement medical benefits for a military rape trauma syndrome.

The defense attacked the case from every angle, but the panel could not get over the Soldier’s admission to CID and ultimately convicted him.

The defense alleged that, during the trial, the prosecution failed to turn over exculpatory evidence and will appeal the case on Brady violation issues.

That notwithstanding, this case sets an example of why service members need to be suspect of law enforcement when they are facing allegations of sexual assault and to contact a qualified attorney at the earliest possible opportunity. Speaking to law enforcement without the benefit of an attorney can have dreadful consequences.

At sentencing, the government asked the jury to confine the accused for 15 years. Bilecki presented a compelling sentencing case and the jury ultimately sentenced our client to six years confinement and a dishonorable discharge.

Result:

  • 6 years confinement and dishonorable discharge
Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on google
Google+
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on email
Email
Case ResultsCourt Martial Case ResultsViolent Crimes Case Results

Attempted Murder, Aggravated Assault, Reckless Driving & More Charges | Case Results

Case Results: All charges were withdrawn and dismissed Location Schofield Barracks, Hawaii Branch of Military and Rank Army E-6 Charges: Attempted Murder Aggravated Assault Reckless …

Read More →
Case ResultsCourt Martial Case Results

Marine E-5 – Fraternization, Drinking on Duty and More | Case Result

June 2018 Rank: Marine E-5 Location:  Camp Hansen, Okinawa Charges: False Official Statement Fraternization Drinking on Duty Unauthorized Absence Result:   Matter disposed of at …

Read More →
Case ResultsSexual Offense Case Results

Soldier (Army E-4) with Dropped Charges of Sexual Assault and Violence

SEXUAL ASSAULT ALLEGATIONS DROPPED, DV MATTER DISPOSED OF AT NJP May 2018 Location: Schofield Barracks, Hawaii Rank: Army E-4 Charges: Sexual Assault Domestic Violence Result: …

Read More →
Scroll to Top

Request A FREE Case Evaluation

You deserve a fighting chance on your day in court. When it comes time to decide who your attorney will be to defend your UCMJ charges, make that decision count.***

*** All information submitted will be kept confidential and private. An attorney client relationship is not established by submitting this initial contact information to our office.