Shaken Baby and Abusive Head Trauma Defense in the Military

In the military, a shaken baby or abusive head trauma (AHT) allegation is not one charge. Depending on the facts, the government may charge attempted murder under Article 80, murder under Article 118, manslaughter under Article 119, aggravated assault under Article 128, child endangerment under Article 119b or domestic violence under Article 128b. These cases usually rest on medical opinion about the cause and timing of the injuries, and the government must still prove the accused’s act, causation and the required mental state beyond a reasonable doubt.

Not one charge

ARTICLE 80

Attempted murder

ARTICLE 118

Murder

ARTICLE 119

Manslaughter

ARTICLE 128

Aggravated assault

ARTICLE 119b

Child endangerment

ARTICLE 128b

Domestic violence

Bilecki Law Group flies in hard-hitting attorneys anywhere in the world to defend service members accused of injuring a child or causing a child’s death through shaking or abusive head trauma.

Get a Free Case Evaluation

To talk with our firm about a shaken baby or abusive head trauma allegation, call 813-669-3500 or book a free consultation.

You or someone you love has experienced the terrible injury or death of a child. But before you even have a chance to grieve, the government has brought charges against you of attempted murder, aggravated assault or unpremeditated murder.

These allegations are often discussed as shaken baby syndrome (SBS) or abusive head trauma (AHT). AHT is the broader medical term and includes inflicted injury from violent shaking, blunt impact or both.

How Tim Bilecki and Ben Gold Defend Shaken Baby Injury or Death Cases

Tim Bilecki and Ben Gold work your defense together. Tim is a former Army judge advocate who has taken more than 250 courts-martial to verdict; Ben is a former Navy Surface Warfare Officer.

Defending against charges of assault or murder involving a child requires aggressive representation and careful medical review.

Here are just a few of the ways we can turn the case in your favor:

We’ll investigate your history as a parent and the circumstances surrounding the child’s care. Evidence of a pertinent character trait may be admissible, depending on the charge and the military rules of evidence. An unblemished military record does not establish innocence.

We’ll work with appropriately qualified medical experts when the case requires it, to consult with us and possibly take the stand. These experts will review autopsy results, X-rays and other medical evidence to assess the prosecution’s explanation and any alternative supported by the findings.

Who else had access to the child? Were there underlying medical conditions which could have contributed to the injury or death? Does the proposed timing fit the medical findings and the child’s care?

It takes time to build a strong defense. Contact us today to discuss the allegations and the medical evidence.

Get a Free Case Evaluation

Child Injury Case Results

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Ignoring the government’s aggressive action toward you may be your first impulse. But set aside your emotional pain for a moment to consider this:

Medical findings can be powerful evidence, and a conviction does not require an eyewitness. But the government must still prove every element of the charged offense beyond a reasonable doubt. An injury or diagnosis does not automatically establish the accused’s act, causation or required mental state.

The government must still prove, beyond a reasonable doubt

THE ACCUSED’S ACT

CAUSATION

THE REQUIRED MENTAL STATE

An injury or diagnosis does not automatically establish any of them

Depending on the charge and sentence, a conviction can mean decades of confinement, forfeitures and a punitive discharge or dismissal. Reduction in grade and the available form of punitive separation depend on your military status. Effects on military benefits depend on the benefit and the applicable rules.

The accusations can take a toll on your social life and relationships. Being accused does not mean the government has proved its case.

The accusations may also lead to a separate child protection investigation involving your other children.

A desire to grieve is understandable, but failing to defend yourself could jeopardize your future. Now is the time to fight back against charges involving shaken baby injuries or death.

Bilecki Law Group will defend you against an unjust prosecution that wants to see you behind bars. One call to our office is the first step to protecting your reputation.

Get a Free Case Evaluation

Shaken Baby Injuries and Deaths: The Facts about Your Case

General courts-martial trials that involve a shaken baby injury and death are emotionally charged events for everyone involved. Your defense needs to keep the focus on admissible evidence and what the government can prove about the actual charge.

Medical evidence, expert testimony and any autopsy findings can be central to these cases. A diagnosis should consider the full history, examination and imaging, with appropriate testing for other medical explanations. Serious injury from a short fall is rare, but not impossible. Any alternative must fit the documented injuries and circumstances. Imaging and retinal findings do not, by themselves, establish a precise injury time.

For a case tried before court-martial members, allegations involving a child can evoke strong emotion. The defense must test the medical and other evidence and hold the government to its burden of proof.

You Are Not Alone

Your case will require military defense attorneys who can examine both the law and the medical evidence. Bilecki Law Group is prepared to fight for you in court.

Hire Bilecki Law Group to fight charges involving shaken baby deaths or injuries in the military.

To talk with our firm about a shaken baby or abusive head trauma allegation, call 813-669-3500 or book a free consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Sentencing Should I Expect for Shaken Baby Injuries and Deaths?

Sentencing will depend on the charges of conviction, the offense dates, and the evidence in aggravation, mitigation and extenuation. There is no standalone “shaken baby” charge under the UCMJ.

Possible charges include attempted murder under Article 80, murder under Article 118, manslaughter under Article 119, assault under Article 128 and child endangerment under Article 119b. Domestic violence under Article 128b may also be alleged when its relationship and other requirements are met. Article 119b requires a duty of care for a child under 16 and endangerment by design or culpable negligence; an injury alone does not establish those elements.

Examples of the confinement limits are:

Charged offenseMaximum confinementConfinement parameter when the newer system applies
Article 119: involuntary manslaughter of a child under 1615 yearsCategory 3: 30 to 120 months
Article 119b: endangerment by design causing grievous bodily harm8 yearsCategory 3: 30 to 96 months, capped at the eight-year maximum
Article 119b: culpable negligence causing grievous bodily harm3 yearsCategory 2: 1 to 36 months
Article 128: aggravated assault causing grievous bodily harm to a child under 168 yearsCategory 3: 30 to 96 months, capped at the eight-year maximum

Murder under Article 118(1) or (4) requires death or life imprisonment unless the accused is otherwise sentenced under an Article 53a plea agreement. Death requires the applicable capital procedures and findings. In qualifying noncapital cases, these are Category 6 offenses with a parameter of life with eligibility for parole. Murder under Article 118(2) or (3) carries a maximum of life imprisonment, with no death penalty. These are Category 5 offenses with a parameter of 240 to 480 months, or 20 to 40 years. Life without eligibility for parole may be authorized when life imprisonment is otherwise authorized; parole eligibility does not assure release.

Attempted murder under Article 80 may carry life imprisonment. The usual 20-year attempt cap does not apply, but death and the completed offense’s mandatory minimum do not apply either. Its confinement category depends on the underlying offense.

The maximum punishment for the four offenses in the table may also include forfeiture of all pay and allowances and a dishonorable discharge. Reduction to E-1 may be imposed on enlisted members. Commissioned officers, including commissioned warrant officers, and cadets or midshipmen may face dismissal.

The confinement parameters apply in noncapital general courts-martial when every offense of conviction occurred on or after 28 December 2023. The judge ordinarily must sentence within the applicable parameter unless specific facts justify a departure, explained in writing. The lawful maximum, forum limits, accepted plea terms and rules about concurrent or consecutive confinement also matter. Multiple charges do not automatically require consecutive maximum terms. Earlier conduct requires the law applicable at that time.

Can Service Members Win Cases of Shaken Baby Deaths or Injuries?

Yes. An outright win is possible.

The absence of an eyewitness does not prevent a conviction; the government may rely on circumstantial evidence. The medical findings, the history and the other evidence all require careful evaluation.

The prosecution must prove every element of the charged offense, including any required causation and mental state, beyond a reasonable doubt. This isn’t always simple. An accidental fall or another medical cause may be relevant when it fits the documented injuries and circumstances.

In United States v. Davis, the accused argued that his child had been injured in an incident involving a car seat. He was convicted of involuntary manslaughter. The Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces later set aside the findings and sentence because of an instructional error and authorized a rehearing. That decision was not an acquittal or a finding that shaking had been disproved.

What Is the Difference Between Shaken Baby Syndrome and Abusive Head Trauma?

Shaken baby syndrome is the term most people know. Abusive head trauma is the broader medical term, and it includes inflicted injury from violent shaking, blunt impact or both. Either label is a medical conclusion, and the defense can test the findings and history behind it.

Can a Short Fall Cause These Injuries?

Serious injury from a short fall is rare, but not impossible. Any alternative explanation must fit the documented injuries and the circumstances, which is why the defense needs qualified medical experts to review the imaging, records and history.

Can Doctors Tell Exactly When the Injury Happened?

Not from imaging and retinal findings alone. Timing matters because it can decide who had access to the child, so the defense tests the proposed timing against the medical findings and the child’s care.

What Charges Can Come From a Shaken Baby Allegation?

There is no standalone shaken baby charge. Depending on the facts, the government may charge attempted murder, murder, manslaughter, aggravated assault, child endangerment or domestic violence. The charge sets the elements the government must prove and the maximum punishment.

Will Family Advocacy or Child Protective Services Get Involved?

Often. The military’s Family Advocacy Program reviews child abuse allegations involving military families, and civilian child protective services may open a separate case involving your other children. For more, read Family Advocacy Program (FAP) and Incident Determination Committee Defense.

If you are accused of injuring a child or causing a child’s death through shaking or abusive head trauma, contact Bilecki Law Group for a free case evaluation.

To talk with our firm about a shaken baby or abusive head trauma allegation, call 813-669-3500 or book a free consultation.

Get a Free Case Evaluation

Call 813-669-3500Book your case review