Article 83: Malingering

At Bilecki Law Group, we defend service members from charges of malingering under Article 83 of the UCMJ. We understand that every service member is more than the sum of the charges against them and we fight for your career, benefits, and freedom.

Facing an Article 83 charge? See how our court martial defense lawyers handle these cases. Related result: Marine Charged with Attempt to Miss Deployment Receives Summary Court-Martial Disposition. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Get Case Evaluation

How To Fight And Defeat Charges Under Article 83

If you are facing charges under Article 83, there are a couple of scenarios we need to examine. The first is that you were indeed ill, you didn’t harm yourself, and your command does not believe you. The second is that perhaps you did indeed make an error in judgement and now you are fighting for your career so that one mistake doesn’t end it all. In either case, you need to fight. You cannot count on the command to build your defense for you.

There are several strategies we can employ to fight these charges and it starts with making no concessions to the prosecution. Article 83 has very specific elements that must be satisfied to find you guilty and we are going to meet them there with a fight every single time. Next, we’re going to thoroughly examine the medical facts at hand. Was your command trying to pull a Patton by diagnosing PTSD as cowardice? Is some Grunt officer trying to play Doctor when you have good medical documentation to back you up?

If your buddy wanted to play the Blue Falcon and rat you out because they were in trouble themselves, we’ll call them out. If we need to get your command on the stand and take its accusations apart, we’ll do that as well. The attorneys at Bilecki don’t have to worry about their own military career and so we don’t mind upsetting the brass in the process. This is your career. This is your life. You need someone who is going to fight for you till the bitter end.

If you are under investigation or facing charges of malingering, you need to get ready to fight. You can reach out to us for a free case evaluation, and we’ll always shoot you straight on what you are facing. This is your career. Your life. Reach out to us and we’ll take the fight right to the heart of the military justice system and when we fight, we fight to win.

What is Article 83 of the UCMJ?

Malingering under Article 83 of the UCMJ requires the government to prove three things beyond a reasonable doubt:

  1. You were assigned to, or were aware of a prospective assignment to or availability for, work, duty, or service.
  2. You feigned illness, physical disablement, mental lapse, or mental derangement, or intentionally inflicted injury upon yourself.
  3. Your purpose or intent was to avoid that work, duty, or service.

For the aggravated form, the government must also prove that the offense was committed in time of war or in a hostile fire pay zone. It is the circumstances of the offense that matter, not simply where or when a future duty was supposed to occur.

This is the current Article 83, effective 1 January 2019. Earlier alleged conduct requires review of the law in effect at that time.

To feign illness is to pretend to be ill. The injury may be inflicted by violent or nonviolent means, or by an act or omission that produces, prolongs, or aggravates sickness or disability. The government still has to prove the required intent to avoid work, duty, or service.

To sum it up, if you pull a Ferris Bueller in the military and fake sick to avoid duty, you could be charged with malingering under Article 83 of the UCMJ. Starving yourself to the point of debility can be self-inflicted injury, but malingering also requires the intent to avoid work, duty, or service. Asking someone else to injure you for that purpose can support the same charge.

The Manual for Courts-Martial also says that bona fide suicide attempts should not be charged as criminal offenses. It says the convening authority should consider matters such as health conditions, personal stressors, and Department of Defense policy on suicide prevention when deciding whether an injury was a bona fide suicide attempt. An injury by itself does not prove malingering.

Can They Charge Me With Malingering If I’m Really Sick?

Genuine illness is not feigned illness. The government must prove the conduct and intent required by Article 83; a commander’s suspicion is not proof of either. That is why we examine the medical records, the duty involved, and the evidence of what you intended.

GENUINE ILLNESS

Is not feigned illness

THE GOVERNMENT MUST PROVE

The conduct and intent required by Article 83

A commander’s suspicion is not proof of either

Article 83 is a damning article for many service members, especially when their command doubts an illness from the start. That doubt can be exacerbated by the “sickbay commandos” who do indeed seek to find any way to avoid duty and, if they have to fake illness to earn a trip to sickbay, they’ll gladly do so.

But someone else’s malingering does not prove yours. If your command wants to make an example out of you despite medical evidence that you were genuinely ill, we will challenge that decision. Charging a genuinely ill service member simply because the command does not believe the illness is real is not a substitute for proving the offense.

A Military Culture That Doubts and Frowns Upon Illness

Perhaps one of the more famous incidents of a command doubting an illness would be the General George Patton slap heard around the world. What most people don’t realize is that there were two separate incidents. On 3 August 1943, General Patton was visiting the 15th Evacuation Hospital when he came across a soldier who had been admitted for treatment. He asked the Private what was wrong and the Private replied, “I guess I can’t take it.” That’s when Patton cursed the soldier and slapped him with his gloves. It turns out, the soldier had malaria and dysentery.

Then, just a week later, at the 93rd Evacuation Hospital, he came across another Private. This time, the Private was lying on a bed and after Patton asked what was wrong with him, he replied “it’s my nerves.” That’s when Patton lost it. He screamed and cursed at the soldier calling him a coward and proceeded to slap the soldier. Patton even reached for his pistol and was still yelling at the soldier suffering from battle fatigue as he was leaving the tent.

Word of the slapping had made its way to Eisenhower, who ordered Patton to make amends. Patton apologized to both soldiers and the medical personnel, and expressed regret to his divisions. Eisenhower kept him in command of Seventh Army. When the story reached the public in November 1943, Eisenhower stood by that decision.

Military culture doesn’t offer a great deal of easy sympathy for those who won’t fight. But a service member with a genuine physical or mental illness is not a coward because a commander says so. We have much more medical information at our disposal today. If your command is dismissing that information, we need to put it in front of the people deciding your case.

What’s The Worst That Can Happen To Me Under Article 83 of the UCMJ?

The stakes are serious, but the maximum punishment is not a prediction of your sentence. For enlisted members, each form of malingering permits a dishonorable discharge, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, and reduction to E-1. The maximum confinement depends on what the government proves:

OffenseMaximum confinement
Feigning illness, physical disablement, mental lapse, or mental derangement1 year
The same offense in time of war or in a hostile fire pay zone3 years
Intentional self-inflicted injury5 years
Intentional self-inflicted injury in time of war or in a hostile fire pay zone10 years

Maximum confinement, in years

Feigning
1
Feigning · time of war or hostile fire pay zone
3
Intentional self-inflicted injury
5
Self-inflicted injury · time of war or hostile fire pay zone
10 · the total, not added to another term
0510

The ten-year maximum is the total for that aggravated self-injury offense, not ten years added to another confinement term.

Dismissal, rather than a punitive discharge, applies to commissioned officers, including commissioned warrant officers, and cadets and midshipmen. A dishonorable discharge may apply to enlisted members and uncommissioned warrant officers. A dismissal or dishonorable discharge may be adjudged only by a general court-martial. Reduction to E-1 applies only to enlisted members. The court-martial’s jurisdiction, the law applicable on the offense date, and any plea agreement can further limit the sentence.

Sentencing Guidelines

For noncapital general and special courts-martial, the sentencing parameter system applies when every offense of conviction occurred on or after 28 December 2023. The military judge must sentence within the applicable confinement range unless specific facts justify a departure. If the judge departs, the record must contain a written statement explaining the factual basis. These ranges do not replace the lawful maximum punishment for the offense or the court-martial’s jurisdictional limits.

OffenseSentencing category or criteriaConfinement range in months
Feigning illness, physical disablement, mental lapse, or mental derangement outside wartime or a hostile fire pay zoneCategory 10–12
Intentional self-inflicted injury outside wartime or a hostile fire pay zoneCategory 21–36
Either form committed in wartime or a hostile fire pay zoneSentencing criteria under Appendix 12DNo assigned category range

For the wartime or hostile fire pay zone offenses, the judge must consider the specific sentencing criteria in Appendix 12D. Those include the accused’s age, experience and mental impairment, the presence of the enemy, the effect on military operations and national security, danger to others, the duty the accused sought to avoid, and whether the offense occurred in occupied territory or an area of contingency operations or active hostilities.

Call 813-669-3500Book your case review