A lot of service members assume that if they hire a civilian attorney, they’re automatically in better hands.
Wrong.
Hiring the wrong civilian military defense attorney can be just as bad—if not worse—than sticking with the JAG lawyer the military assigns to you.
I’ve seen it happen time and time again. A service member, facing the fight of his life, thinks hiring any civilian lawyer is the solution. He hires a guy who just left JAG, set up his own firm last year, and is trying to make a quick buck. The lawyer charges a lower fee, takes on way too many cases, and doesn’t have the skill to handle the pressure of a real court-martial.
And the result? Disaster.
A real military defense attorney isn’t just someone with a law degree. It’s someone who’s a fighter—someone who knows how to win when everything is on the line.
Here’s how to spot a winner—and how to avoid hiring a loser who’ll cost you everything.
The Military Justice System is Built to Convict You
Before we get into picking the right defense attorney, let’s talk about what you’re up against.
The military justice system isn’t like civilian court. It’s not designed to protect your rights. It’s designed to make examples out of people.
- Cases that wouldn’t even be prosecuted in the civilian world can send you to prison in the military.
- Draconian sentencing guidelines mean you’re not looking at small punishments—you’re looking at decades behind bars.
- The system isn’t built for you to win—it’s built for them to win.
That’s why having the right defense attorney isn’t optional. If you don’t have a fighter in your corner, you’re at the mercy of a system that’s set up to steamroll you.
Why Not All Civilian Military Defense Attorneys Are Equal
Just because someone calls themselves a “military defense attorney” doesn’t mean they’re the right person to defend you.
Here’s how bad attorneys end up on military cases:
- They were in JAG for a few years, then decided to open a private practice. They don’t actually have the experience to win real cases.
- They undercharge to get more clients. They take on way too many cases, don’t put in the work, and throw their clients under the bus.
- They don’t understand military culture. Some civilian lawyers think they can just “learn as they go.” If they weren’t in the military themselves, walk away.
- They lack trial experience. You need a lawyer who has handled hundreds of trials, not someone who’s still figuring things out.
What to Look for in a Military Defense Attorney
If your future is on the line, you don’t just need a lawyer. You need a fighter.
Here’s how you find one:
- They’ve spent at least 10 years defending service members– Anything less? Walk away. If they just left JAG and are “figuring it out,” they’re not ready for a high-stakes court-martial.
- They have a history of winning tough cases– Not just plea deals. Not just quick settlements. Real, hard-fought wins.
- They know the military inside and out– They speak the language, they understand the culture, and they know how commands operate.
- They have the right personality – If your attorney doesn’t sound confident, doesn’t look like a fighter (yes that matters), and doesn’t make you believe they can win? Move on.
- They don’t make excuses—they win– Some attorneys only want easy cases to pad their record. You want someone who thrives on high-pressure fights.
Winners Win at Life—Losers Lose Cases
Here’s something most people don’t think about: if your lawyer is a loser in life, why would they be a winner in court?
I want someone representing me who is sharp, disciplined, and thrives under pressure. If they can’t keep their own life together, how the hell are they supposed to handle the stress of a high-stakes court-martial?
A winning attorney is:
- Disciplined. They take care of themselves! They look sharp. They’re on top of their game.
- Confident. Not arrogant—confident. They believe in their ability because they’ve proven themselves.
- Mentally strong. If they crumble under stress, they’re not the guy you want fighting for your freedom.
The Biggest Misconceptions About Hiring a Civilian Attorney
A lot of service members make huge mistakes when hiring a civilian lawyer.
- Mistake #1: Thinking any civilian attorney is better than a military one.
Some JAG attorneys are damn good at what they do. In some cases, you’re better off sticking with them than hiring a weak civilian lawyer who has no idea what he’s doing.
- Mistake #2: Shopping for the cheapest lawyer.
If a lawyer is undercharging, ask yourself why. Are they struggling to get clients? Are they taking too many cases to make ends meet? A cheap lawyer can cost you everything.
- Mistake #3: Assuming every attorney actually fights.
Some attorneys just want quick plea deals so they can move on to the next case. You need someone who is willing to go to trial and fight for you.
Hire a Fighter, Not a Loser
If you’re facing a military trial, don’t gamble with your future.
- Hire someone who has proven they can win.
- Hire someone who thrives under pressure.
- Hire someone who believes in your case and knows how to fight.
Because in a system that’s designed to convict you, the only way to win is to have the right fighter in your corner.
Defending Service Members Globally
Wherever Duty Calls, Our Defense Follows
