Maximum Punishment:
-
DD
-
9 years confinement
-
Total forfeiture
-
Reduction to E-1
-
Federal felony conviction
-
Sex offender registration
-
Loss of retirement
Facts:
An Army Command Sergeant Major (CSM) was charged at a general court martial with abusive sexual conduct, indecent acts and fraternization following an incident that took place between him and his driver, an Army Specialist, inside their government vehicle.
The situation began when the Specialist boastfully claimed the size of his genitalia and attempted to “prove it” by exposing himself to the CSM while driving. Responding to this inappropriate behavior, the CSM grabbed the Specialist’s ACU trousers and boxer shorts, instructing him to “put it away” and cease his actions. This interaction led to the Specialist alleging multiple sexual assaults by the CSM.
Throughout the investigation and the Article 32 hearing, the defense team, led by Mr. Tim Bilecki, successfully challenged the Specialist’s credibility. The defense exposed numerous inconsistencies and lies in his allegations, significantly weakening the prosecution’s case. However, there was evidence in discovery regarding the extent of the CSM’s and SPC’s relationship that would likely be viewed by a jury as fraternization.
Given the emerging evidence and the Specialist’s damaged credibility, the defense strategically decided to plead guilty to the lesser charge of fraternization as part of a plea deal. This plea was part of a toughly negotiated agreement with the prosecution after extensive pre-trial litigation. The agreement effectively dismissed the more serious charges of abusive sexual conduct and indecent acts.
Bilecki continued the fight at sentencing, presenting the evidence in extenuation and mitigation after the sexual allegations had been removed from the case. The CSM received a one-grade reduction for fraternization. No confinement and no punitive discharge. The final punishment was for the relationship the evidence supported, not the sexual assaults the Specialist had alleged.
Prior results do not predict future outcomes.
