UCMJ Article 134: Negligent Homicide
At Bilecki Law Group, we defend service members against charges under Article 134 of the UCMJ. This includes, but is not limited to, charges of negligent homicide under the General Article.
Facing an Article 134 charge? See how our murder and manslaughter defense lawyers handle these cases. Related result: Bilecki Defeats Alleged Fatal Hit and Run Case: Negligent Homicide Dismissed and Full Acquittal at Trial. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
How To Fight Back Against Negligent Homicide Charges
The simple truth is that service in the military is a dangerous affair and one doesn’t need to find themselves in combat for that to be true. Massive equipment on the move, frequent handling of explosives, rounds flying through the air and it is enough for a simple mistake to prove deadly. If you are finding yourself facing the charge of negligent homicide, it is not a foregone conclusion that you are at fault, though the prosecution will make it seem so.
This is also true if the death occurred outside the normal bounds of military service. When alcohol is involved, an off-duty gathering can end in tragedy. A command may want answers quickly, but the fact that someone died does not establish that you committed a crime. The investigation still has to account for what each person did and what actually caused the death.
If the command is trying to make a public example out of you, we are not going to accept its account just because someone put it in an investigative report. We examine the sequence of events, the duty you actually had, the safety procedures, the equipment and the medical explanation for the death. Witness accounts, photographs, video, maintenance records and training records can change the picture. We want those answers before the government turns a tragedy into your conviction.
WHAT WE EXAMINE
Witness accounts, photographs, video, maintenance and training records can change the picture
Tim Bilecki and Ben Gold work your defense together. Tim is a former Army judge advocate, and Ben is a former Navy Surface Warfare Officer. When the case calls for a medical expert, an accident reconstruction specialist or an independent investigator, we identify the help the defense needs. We test the government’s explanation and prepare to present the facts it leaves out. We also prepare for sentencing when necessary, without treating an accusation as a reason to concede guilt.
If you are facing charges of negligent homicide under Article 134, reach out to us and we’ll shoot you straight on exactly what you are facing. Your free initial consultation is with an attorney. We can discuss the accusation, what is at stake and whether retaining us makes sense for your defense. Give us a call and get us into that fight.
What Is Negligent Homicide Under Article 134?
Negligent homicide under Article 134 is an unlawful killing caused by simple negligence, under circumstances satisfying the required connection to good order and discipline or the reputation of the armed forces. The prosecution does not have to prove that you intended to kill or injure someone. It still has to prove your negligent conduct caused the death, along with every other element.
What Must The Prosecution Prove?
These are plain-English summaries of the elements. The prosecution must prove each one beyond a reasonable doubt.
- A person died.
- The death resulted from your act or failure to act.
- The killing was unlawful.
- The act or failure to act that caused the death amounted to simple negligence.
- Under the circumstances, your conduct prejudiced good order and discipline in the armed forces, was of a nature to bring discredit upon the armed forces, or both.
Simple negligence means a failure to exercise the care a reasonably careful person would exercise under the same circumstances, where there is a duty to exercise that care. It is a lower degree of negligence than the culpable negligence required for that form of involuntary manslaughter. Identifying the duty, the conduct that fell short and its connection to the death is essential.
SIMPLE NEGLIGENCE · NEGLIGENT HOMICIDE
A failure to exercise the care a reasonably careful person would exercise, where there is a duty to exercise it
CULPABLE NEGLIGENCE · INVOLUNTARY MANSLAUGHTER
A higher degree of negligence, required for that form of Article 119
Calling a death an accident does not resolve the charge. The accident defense concerns an unintentional result of a lawful act performed in a lawful manner, without negligence. We examine whether the facts support that defense or instead show a failure in the government’s proof of duty, negligence, causation or another element.
THE ACCIDENT DEFENSE
An unintentional result of a lawful act performed in a lawful manner, without negligence
OR A FAILURE IN THE GOVERNMENT’S PROOF
The government must prove the applicable Article 134 requirement beyond a reasonable doubt. Prejudice to good order and discipline must be reasonably direct and palpable, rather than a remote effect. Conduct of a nature to bring discredit upon the armed forces is conduct tending to damage the service’s reputation. An accusation does not establish either one.
Maximum Punishment And Sentencing Parameters
The maximum punishment for negligent homicide includes a dishonorable discharge, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, and confinement for three years. Reduction to E-1 applies to enlisted members; commissioned officers face dismissal rather than an enlisted punitive discharge. The authorized punishment also depends on military status and the type of court-martial.
For a noncapital general court-martial when every offense of conviction occurred on or after 28 December 2023, this is a Category 2 offense with a confinement range of 1 to 36 months. The judge must sentence within that range unless specific facts justify a departure, with a written statement explaining the factual basis. The offense maximum, the limits of the court hearing the case and any plea agreement must also be checked. Earlier conduct requires the law applicable at that time.
