At Bilecki Law Group, we defend service members against charges involving worthless checks under Article 123a. You have fought honorably for your country. Now let us fight for you.
That’s because in most cases, what we see are young service members trying to take care of their family on a limited income. There exists the misconception that BAH and military pay can cover any and all expenses incurred by a family. That’s just not the case and not every command is sympathetic or supportive of young military families. A returned check can create a serious problem, but it does not automatically prove the criminal intent required by Article 123a.
What Must the Government Prove Under Article 123a?
Article 123a distinguishes a check issued to procure something of value with intent to defraud from one issued to pay a past-due obligation or for another purpose with intent to deceive. The government must also prove the required knowledge that there were not, or would not be, sufficient funds or credit for full payment when the instrument was presented.
Check, worthless, with intent to defraud - For a service member to be found guilty, the prosecution must satisfy the following four elements:
(1) That (state the time and place alleged), the accused (made) (drew) (uttered) (delivered) to (state the name of the payee or other alleged victim) a (check) (draft) (money order) drawn upon the __________ (Bank) (__________), to wit: (describe the check, draft, money order, or, if set forth in the specification, make reference to it);
(2) That the accused did so for the purpose of procuring an article or thing of value, to wit: (state the article/thing alleged);
(3) That the accused committed the act with intent to defraud; and
(4). That, at the time of the (making) (drawing) (uttering) (delivering) of the instrument, the accused knew that (he/she) (the maker/drawer) did not or would not have sufficient (funds in) (credit with) the (bank) (depository) for the payment thereof in full upon its presentment.
Maximum Punishment: Value of $1,000 or less comes with a bad conduct discharge, total forfeiture of all pay and allowances, 6 months confinement and reduction in rank to E-1.
Value of more than $1,000 comes with a dishonorable discharge, total forfeiture of all pay and allowances, 5 years confinement and reduction in rank to E-1.
Check, worthless, with intent to deceive - For a service member to be found guilty, the prosecution must satisfy the following four elements:
(1) That (state the time and place alleged), the accused (made) (drew) (uttered) (delivered) to (state the name of the payee or other alleged victim) a (check) (draft) (money order) drawn upon the __________ (Bank) (__________), to wit: (describe the check, draft, money order, or, if set forth in the specification, make reference to it);
(2) That the accused did so for the purpose of (effecting the payment of a past due obligation) (__________);
(3) That the accused committed the act with intent to deceive; and
(4) That, at the time of the (making) (drawing) (uttering) (delivering) of the instrument, the accused knew that (he) (she) (the maker/drawer) did not or would not have sufficient (funds in) (credit with) the (bank) (depository) for the payment thereof in full upon its presentment.
Maximum Punishment: Bad conduct discharge, total forfeiture of all pay and allowances, 6 months confinement and reduction in rank to E-1.
Reduction to E-1 applies to enlisted personnel. Dismissal, rather than a dishonorable or bad-conduct discharge, is the authorized punitive separation for commissioned officers, including commissioned warrant officers, and cadets and midshipmen. The authorized punishment also depends on the offense date and court-martial forum.
Maximum Punishments and Sentencing Parameters
For noncapital general and special courts-martial, the sentencing parameter system applies when every offense of conviction occurred on or after 28 December 2023. The military judge must sentence within the applicable confinement range unless specific facts justify a departure. If the judge departs, the record must contain a written statement explaining the factual basis. These ranges do not replace the lawful maximum punishment for the offense or the court-martial’s jurisdictional limits. For offenses assigned sentencing criteria instead of a category, the judge must consider those criteria.
The ranges below are stated in months and are limited where the offense has a lower confinement maximum. A special court-martial can impose no more than its own authorized limit, even when an offense or category allows more. The maximum is not a prediction of the sentence in your case.
| Offense | Maximum confinement | Category | Range in months |
|---|---|---|---|
| Intent to defraud, amount $1,000 or less | 6 months | Category 1 | 0–6 |
| Intent to defraud, amount more than $1,000 | 5 years | Category 2 | 1–36 |
| Intent to deceive | 6 months | Category 1 | 0–6 |
Fighting Back Against Worthless-Check Charges
The check, bank records, account balance, available credit, timing and communications all matter. So does what you knew when the instrument was issued. We will test the government’s claim of criminal intent against that record. A financial mistake and a deliberate fraud are different allegations, and the prosecution still has to prove the charge it brought.
If you are accused of a worthless-check offense, contact Bilecki Law Group for a confidential consultation. Your military career, your reputation and your freedom could be on the line. Tim Bilecki and Ben Gold prepare your defense together and represent service members from Tampa, Florida, throughout the United States and worldwide.
