UCMJ Article 128b Strangulation Military Court Martial Defense

Strangulation under Article 128b of the UCMJ means assaulting a spouse, intimate partner, dating partner or immediate family member by intentionally, knowingly or recklessly impeding normal breathing or blood circulation through pressure on the throat or neck. Suffocation means impeding normal breathing by covering the mouth, nose or both. No visible injury, loss of consciousness or intent to kill is required. The maximum punishment is a dishonorable discharge, forfeiture of all pay and allowances and 8 years of confinement, or 11 years when the person was a child under 16. Article 128b is a covered offense under the special trial counsel system.

Bilecki Law Group flies in hard-hitting attorneys anywhere in the world to defend service members against false allegations of domestic abuse and strangulation.

Get Free Case Evaluation

To talk with our firm about an Article 128b strangulation allegation, call 813-669-3500 or book a free consultation.

To the outside observer, in all things Uniform Code of Military Justice, dedicating a page to the defense of service members charged with strangulation under Article 128b may seem odd. It is not that we are sitting around waiting for Jack the Ripper to give us a call. It is that we are seeing more and more strangulation cases built around private conduct in the bedroom later repackaged as criminal assault.

People call it choking. More clinically, it is often described as erotic asphyxiation. Whatever label you use, it is not new, it is not rare, and it is not confined to any one age bracket or to civilians. It happens in barracks rooms, off-post apartments, hotel rooms, and every other place where adults make messy decisions. The military is no exception.

The problem is what happens later.

In the military, a bedroom allegation does not stay in the bedroom. It becomes a CID problem, an NCIS problem, an OSI problem, depending on the branch. It becomes a command problem. It becomes a SHARP problem or a SAPR problem, depending on the service. It becomes a clearance problem and often a career problem before anyone has done the hard work of separating accusation from proof. Once the word “strangulation” lands in the file, the label starts doing work that the evidence may not.

That is not proof. That is momentum.

Article 128b domestic violence is a covered offense under the special trial counsel system. When a special trial counsel exercises authority over the case, that prosecutor controls specified charging and disposition decisions. The conduct date and actual exercise of authority matter. The defense needs to reach the person with authority before the government’s account hardens.

COVERED OFFENSE

Article 128b domestic violence, under the special trial counsel system

WHEN SPECIAL TRIAL COUNSEL EXERCISES AUTHORITY

That prosecutor controls specified charging and disposition decisions

How Tim Bilecki and Ben Gold Fight These Cases

These cases are not won by hand-wringing. They are won by getting into the facts early and refusing to let the government tell the story unopposed.

Tim Bilecki and Ben Gold work your defense together. Tim is a former Army judge advocate who has taken more than 250 courts-martial to verdict; Ben is a former Navy Surface Warfare Officer.

That starts with digital forensics.

In many of these cases, the most important evidence is sitting in a phone, a cloud account, deleted messages, photos, app data, a text chain, a Signal thread, or metadata showing when things were sent, deleted, or changed. We work with digital forensic examiners to preserve and analyze communications before and after the alleged incident, recover deleted material where possible, and test whether the complaining witness’s story actually matches the messages and other evidence. In some cases, the messages show fantasy talk about choking, rough sex, prior consensual conduct, or post-encounter communications that look nothing like someone describing a criminal assault. In some cases, the alleged victim later denies those communications existed. A properly preserved extraction may establish that those communications existed. Their meaning still has to be examined in context.

That is how cases get turned.

We have handled and won these cases, including cases where digital extractions exposed prior consensual choking talk, post-incident messaging inconsistent with assault, and medical theories that did not hold up under expert review.

We also use medical expertise where it matters. A forensic nurse examiner, sexual-assault forensic examiner, or other qualified medical expert can review records, photographs, timing, symptom descriptions, and claimed injuries to assess whether the evidence is actually consistent with strangulation, inconsistent with strangulation, or too thin to support the narrative the government is trying to sell. Things like voice changes, swallowing changes, breathing changes, neck tenderness, petechiae, subconjunctival hemorrhage, neurologic findings, vomiting, and other symptoms matter. Just as important, the absence of visible external injury does not automatically answer the question one way or the other. That is why these cases require real expert review, not guesswork by investigators.

That matters because prosecutors love an easy win. They love a label that sounds inherently awful. They love a case where the accused made a partial admission and the rest can be filled in by indignation. What Bilecki Law Group does is deny them that easy win.

We test the allegation. We test the timeline. We test the motive. We test the messages, the photos, the app data, the deleted communications, and the medical theory. We test whether the complaining witness is telling the same story now that they told before. And we test whether the government can actually prove the charged offense, including unlawful force or violence, after the full context is examined.

Speak with defense counsel before answering investigators’ questions about the allegation or voluntarily consenting to a search. Preserve evidence you lawfully possess; do not delete or alter messages, approach the complainant to discuss the case, or violate a protective or no-contact order.

Strangulation Case Results

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Contact Bilecki Law Group

If you are facing charges of strangulation or suffocation under Article 128b, reach out to us for a free strategy session.

Yes, you are going to have to talk about private facts. Fine. We have defended enough service members to know that embarrassment is not a defense strategy, and withholding the facts from your own lawyer leaves us without the full picture. There is nothing you are going to tell us that is going to shock us. What matters now is protecting your freedom, your career, your retirement, and your name.

What they are doing to you is not right. We will fight like hell on your behalf.

Is Erotic Asphyxiation a Crime Under UCMJ Article 128b?

Consent to sex does not by itself resolve a strangulation charge. We have to examine the actual contact, what was communicated, whether breathing or circulation was impeded, and which defenses the law permits.

General James Mattis once said, “Frankly, Senator, I have never cared much about two consenting adults and who they go to bed with.” Fair enough. We agree. What two consenting adults do in bed is none of our business and should not be the business of the UCMJ either. The problem comes later, when one of those two consenting adults says it was not consensual after all. That is when a private sexual encounter becomes a strangulation case.

Service members are adults. They get into relationships. They do embarrassing things. They do kinky things. None of that makes it automatically criminal.

Consensual sexual activity is not automatically criminal, but a request to be choked does not automatically make the particular use of force lawful. An allegation that pressure on the neck impeded breathing or blood circulation requires a different legal analysis. The government still has to prove the offense it charged.

That does not mean every allegation is false. It means the government does not get to skip straight from a loaded label to a conviction. The legal question is not whether the conduct sounds rough, weird, embarrassing, or outside the mainstream. The legal question is whether the government can prove beyond a reasonable doubt that there was strangulation or suffocation, that any force used was unlawful, and that the allegation is true as framed by the prosecution.

That is where the real fight is.

The government loves the word “strangulation” because it sounds dispositive. It is not. The label is not the proof. And in a surprising number of these cases, the government is trying to transform a later accusation into certainty without doing the hard evidentiary work needed to prove what actually happened.

A lover who willingly engaged in erotic asphyxiation can very easily claim strangulation later when they become a lover scorned. That is not a throwaway line. That is motive to fabricate. That is the theory of defense in a real number of cases. See how we expose false allegations of domestic violence.

Private consensual sexual conduct should not be treated as criminal merely because it embarrasses someone. It should not become a felony-level military case simply because the relationship later imploded and the other side found a better narrative. A service member asking a partner to dress up like Abraham Lincoln before sex is odd. A partner asking to be choked during sex is odd to some people too. Fine. Odd is not criminal. Kinky is not criminal. Embarrassing is not criminal. The issue is whether the government can prove a crime, not whether it can make a panel uncomfortable.

A breakup, a delayed report or continued contact does not, by itself, establish a false allegation. We test any claimed motive against the particular messages, accounts and chronology. Evidence of sexual behavior may also be subject to Military Rule of Evidence 412; relevance does not automatically make it admissible.

Why These Allegations Are Showing Up More Often

Porn is normalizing this behavior. The amount of porn that a service member has at their fingertips is skewing the norms of sexual interactions. Young men often think this is what sex is supposed to look like thanks to porn and young women feel that it is their obligation to oblige. This is not healthy for a variety of reasons, and the legality of the particular conduct still depends on the facts and the offense charged.

The perceived benefits of erotic asphyxiation are also part of it. Some couples believe that risky behavior increases trust and intimacy. Maybe that is true. Maybe it is not. Neither that belief nor a claim of increased pleasure answers whether the particular conduct was lawful. Pressure on the neck can cause serious injury even without visible marks.

Then there is the 50 Shades of Grey effect. Beyond porn, the erotic BDSM thriller movie and book 50 Shades of Grey brought BDSM into the mainstream. Vanilla sex was instantly out and the kinky was somehow normalized. A scene from a book or movie does not decide what is lawful in a real encounter.

That matters because these allegations so often arise out of consensual sexual relationships and only later get reframed as criminal.

How These Cases Actually Arise

When a charge of strangulation under Article 128b comes up, it is not always the case that the alleged victim was sitting in their barracks room reading their Bible when the accused walked in and started to choke them.

Some allegations instead arise from a sexual relationship.

Usually there is a relationship. Usually there is alcohol. Usually there is prior sexual history. Usually there are messages before the encounter and messages after it. Often there is fantasy talk, rough-sex talk, jealousy, cheating, retaliation, a breakup, or some other emotional detonation after the fact. It is only later, sometimes months and even a year later, that the alleged victim comes forward and says the choking was not consensual.

In the era of SHARP, SAPR, and OSTC, these delayed allegations are too often treated as if they happened yesterday and were caught on video.

The allegation may come about because the alleged victim found out the accused was seeing someone else in the unit. It may have come about because the alleged victim got into their own trouble with the UCMJ and made the allegation to stop that investigation in its tracks. It may come about because a private act became a public weapon after the relationship imploded. In the current military climate, it takes very little for a service member to see the benefit of making a false allegation and very little for the system to credit it.

What the Government Actually Has to Prove

To convict a service member of assault by strangulation or suffocation under Article 128b, the prosecution still has to prove the elements:

  1. That the accused assaulted a spouse, intimate partner, dating partner or immediate family member of the accused.
  2. That the accused did so by strangulation or suffocation.
  3. That the strangulation or suffocation was done with unlawful force or violence.
  4. When that aggravating circumstance is alleged, that the person was a child under 16.

Strangulation means intentionally, knowingly or recklessly impeding normal breathing or blood circulation by pressure on the throat or neck. Suffocation means intentionally, knowingly or recklessly impeding normal breathing by covering the mouth, nose or both. Visible injury, loss of consciousness and an intent to kill are not required. Touching a neck, by itself, does not establish the required impediment.

STRANGULATION

Impeding normal breathing or blood circulation by pressure on the throat or neck

SUFFOCATION

Impeding normal breathing by covering the mouth, nose or both

Not required

Visible injuryLoss of consciousnessIntent to kill

Article 128 can also apply to aggravated assault by strangulation or suffocation when the specified Article 128b relationship is absent. We examine the actual charge and the law applicable to the alleged conduct date.

ARTICLE 128b

A spouse, intimate partner, dating partner or immediate family member

ARTICLE 128

Aggravated assault by strangulation or suffocation when that relationship is absent · lower maximums

Sometimes the relationship is obvious. Sometimes the act is admitted. Plenty of times it is not. Just a later allegation and a prosecution system eager to credit it.

There may not be a single shred of corroborating evidence. No photograph. No witness. No contemporaneous complaint. No medical finding that cleanly proves what the government says happened. That is why these cases have to be fought, not assumed.

Testimony is evidence. A conviction does not automatically require a photograph, an eyewitness or a medical finding. The question is whether the admissible evidence proves every element beyond a reasonable doubt.

Sometimes the accused is honest and says, “yeah, but she asked me to choke her,” thinking honesty will preserve the context. An admission can become evidence even when you meant to explain the context. Do not assume the investigator will give that context the weight you do.

So the fight is not merely whether these two people had sex. That is not the point. This is not just an intimate-partner case. The fight is whether there was choking at all, whether it was asked for, whether it was consensual, whether the allegation changed over time, what the messages show, what the photos show, what the apps show, what the deleted texts show, what the medical evidence shows, and why the allegation surfaced when it did.

That is the case.

Fighting Charges of Strangulation in the Era of SHARP, SAPR, and OSTC

These allegations can lead to serious charges in civilian courts as well. Unfortunately, service members are fighting more than the ordinary military justice system. They are fighting commands and Office of the Special Trial Counsel prosecutors under enormous pressure to prove to elected officials and senior leaders that they are taking SHARP and SAPR seriously and prosecuting these cases aggressively.

That pressure matters.

The deck is more stacked than it used to be. These are not casual prosecutions. These are the kinds of cases that can get picked up by specially trained prosecutors whose job is to prosecute exactly this kind of allegation. If the government gains momentum early, you will be in for a fight.

An innocent service member should not end up in the brig because an institution fears being accused of disbelieving a complainant. That is why we challenge weak cases before they gain traction.

Maximum Punishments and Sentencing Parameters

Article 128b strangulation or suffocationMaximum confinementCategoryConfinement range in months
Other cases8 years21–36
Child under 1611 years330–120

The offense also authorizes a dishonorable discharge and forfeiture of all pay and allowances, subject to military status and the court’s jurisdiction. Commissioned officers, including commissioned warrant officers, face dismissal rather than a dishonorable discharge. An enlisted member may also be reduced to E-1. A warrant officer who is not commissioned may receive a dishonorable discharge at a general court-martial.

In a noncapital case containing only convictions for conduct on or after 28 December 2023, the military judge generally sentences under the applicable parameter system. The table gives the general-court ranges. An authorized departure requires specific facts and a written explanation. Forum limits and any binding plea agreement also matter. At an ordinary special court-martial, Category 3 or higher uses the jurisdictional 12-month maximum as the parameters, with a lesser sentence permitted on the required factual finding. A maximum or category range is not a prediction of your sentence.

Frequently Asked Questions About Military Strangulation Charges

Is strangulation a felony in the military?

The UCMJ does not label offenses as felonies or misdemeanors. Strangulation under Article 128b carries up to 8 years of confinement and a dishonorable discharge, or 11 years when the person was a child under 16. It is treated as a serious, felony-level charge.

Can you be charged with strangulation if there are no marks?

Yes. Visible injury is not required. The government still has to prove that pressure on the throat or neck impeded normal breathing or blood circulation, so the description of the contact, the reported symptoms and the medical findings matter.

Is consensual choking during sex a crime under the UCMJ?

Consensual sexual activity is not automatically criminal, but consent to sex does not by itself resolve a strangulation charge. The questions are what contact occurred, what was communicated, whether breathing or circulation was impeded and whether the force was unlawful.

What is the difference between Article 128 and Article 128b strangulation?

Article 128b applies when the person is a spouse, intimate partner, dating partner or immediate family member. Without that relationship, the same conduct can be charged as aggravated assault by strangulation or suffocation under Article 128, which carries lower maximums.

Can the alleged victim drop a strangulation charge?

Not necessarily. A complainant changing their mind may matter to the facts, but it does not automatically end the case. Article 128b is a covered offense, and the special trial counsel or the command can move forward. See Can My Spouse Drop the Domestic Violence Case?

What should I do if I am accused of strangulation in the military?

Speak with defense counsel before answering investigators’ questions or consenting to a search. Preserve the messages and other evidence you lawfully possess, do not delete anything, do not contact the complainant about the case, and obey any protective or no-contact order.

Fighting Back Before the Military Buries You Administratively

A service member in one of these cases is often fighting more than a prosecutor. He is fighting a command climate that may already be planning discharge, adverse action, clearance consequences, and reputation damage before the evidence has even been sorted out. Your career can die administratively even where the proof is thin.

That is why waiting is a mistake.

How to beat a strangulation charge under the UCMJ is not by hoping the system will be fair on its own. It is by fighting like hell and ceding nothing to the prosecution. Tim Bilecki spent years inside the military justice system as a senior Army defense counsel. He knows how fast commands move, how investigators think, and how quickly an ugly allegation can harden into institutional certainty if nobody hits back early.

If you are under investigation or facing a strangulation charge under Article 128b, contact Bilecki Law Group for a free case evaluation.

To talk with our firm about an Article 128b strangulation allegation, call 813-669-3500 or book a free consultation.

Get Free Case Evaluation

Call 813-669-3500Book your case review