Family Advocacy Program (FAP) and Incident Determination Committee Defense

The Family Advocacy Program (FAP) is the military’s program for responding to reported domestic abuse and child abuse, and its Incident Determination Committee (IDC) votes on whether an incident “meets criteria” under Department of Defense definitions. The committee uses a preponderance-of-the-information standard, meaning more likely than not, and the accused service member and the member’s lawyer may not attend. A met-criteria finding is entered in the service’s FAP Central Registry, but it is not a criminal conviction, and a commander may not take administrative or disciplinary action based solely on it.

Bilecki Law Group flies in hard-hitting attorneys anywhere in the world to defend service members facing Family Advocacy Program reviews, Incident Determination Committee findings and the domestic violence investigations that run beside them.

Get Free Case Evaluation

To talk with our firm about a Family Advocacy case, call 813-669-3500 or book a free consultation.

Family Advocacy presents itself as help. For many families, it is.

For the service member accused of abuse, it is also a committee vote.

That vote happens in a room you are not allowed into. Your lawyer is not allowed in either. There is no judge, no cross-examination and no requirement that anyone prove anything beyond a reasonable doubt. The question is whether the committee thinks it is more likely than not that abuse occurred.

A lot of service members treat FAP as the soft side of the case. The intake feels like counseling. The provider is polite. The service member talks. Then the finding comes back met criteria, and it lands on the commander’s desk next to the CID, NCIS or OSI file.

That is why the Family Advocacy track has to be defended from the start.

How Tim Bilecki and Ben Gold Fight Family Advocacy Cases

Tim Bilecki and Ben Gold work your defense together. Tim is a former Army judge advocate who has taken more than 250 courts-martial to verdict; Ben is a former Navy Surface Warfare Officer.

We do not treat Family Advocacy as a side issue. The same facts drive the committee vote, the command decision and the criminal case. When one goes badly, the others feel it.

We start with the record. The first report. The messages before and after. The photographs. The medical records. The timeline of the relationship, the separation, the custody fight, the money and the house. What the reporting person said first, and what changed later.

Then we decide what you say, if anything, and to whom. Some service members should not discuss the incident with Family Advocacy before counsel weighs in. Others need a carefully prepared approach to the assessment. That is a judgment made on the facts, not a reflex.

Then we put the other side of the story where it can matter. Your commander may attend the committee meeting and vote on your incident. Before that vote, your commander should have the evidence the report left out.

If the finding comes back met criteria, we pursue reconsideration under your service’s procedure and answer any command action built on it. A met-criteria finding does not decide what happens to your career.

And we keep the criminal case in view the entire time. What happens in the Family Advocacy process can affect what investigators, command and special trial counsel do next.

Family Advocacy Case Results

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

What You Should Do Right Now

If Family Advocacy, your command or investigators have contacted you about a domestic abuse or child abuse report:

  • Do not discuss the incident with Family Advocacy, investigators or command before speaking with defense counsel.
  • Do not ignore Family Advocacy either. Refusals to take part in the assessment are reported to the case staff meeting, so decide with counsel how to respond.
  • Do not contact the reporting person about the case.
  • Obey every term of any military protective order or no-contact order.
  • Preserve the messages, photographs and records you lawfully possess. Do not delete anything.
  • Do not give a false account to anyone.

If investigators want to question you, clearly invoke your right to remain silent and ask for counsel. Our page on domestic violence investigations explains the first steps.

What the Family Advocacy Program Actually Does

FAP is the Department of Defense program for preventing and responding to domestic abuse and child abuse in military families. Reports can come from command, law enforcement, medical providers, schools, family members or the person who says they were harmed.

Once a report comes in, a FAP clinical provider assesses safety and risk. That provider can make protective-measure recommendations to your commander, including a military protective order, weapons removal, relocation or a bar from the installation.

A Clinical Case Staff Meeting then reviews the case for risk, safety monitoring and treatment recommendations. The Incident Determination Committee decides whether the incident meets the DoD definition of abuse.

How a report moves

REPORT

Command, law enforcement, medical providers, schools, family members or the person who says they were harmed

FAP CLINICAL PROVIDER

Assesses safety and risk · protective-measure recommendations to your commander

CLINICAL CASE STAFF MEETING

Risk, safety monitoring and treatment recommendations

INCIDENT DETERMINATION COMMITTEE

Whether the incident meets the DoD definition of abuse

Certain allegations, including unrestricted reports of domestic abuse involving sexual assault or aggravated assault with grievous bodily harm, must be reported immediately to the military criminal investigative organization. That is how a Family Advocacy case and a CID, NCIS or OSI case end up running side by side.

How the Incident Determination Committee Decides

The committee is chaired by the installation commander’s deputy. Its voting members are the chair, the commander’s senior enlisted advisor, a Staff Judge Advocate representative, a law enforcement representative, the FAP manager or clinical supervisor, and a forensic healthcare provider. Your own commander may attend and vote on your incident.

Voting members

The chair: the installation commander’s deputyThe commander’s senior enlisted advisorA Staff Judge Advocate representativeA law enforcement representativeThe FAP manager or clinical supervisorA forensic healthcare provider

MAY ATTEND AND VOTE

Your own commander

MAY NOT ATTEND

You · the person who made the allegation · either side’s lawyer

The standard is a preponderance of the information. A member votes that an incident meets criteria if that is more likely than not.

The committee works through the definition in stages: whether there was an abusive act or failure to act, whether it had the required impact, and whether an exclusion applies. A “does not meet” vote at any stage ends the determination. For a spouse or intimate partner, the categories are physical abuse, sexual abuse, emotional abuse and neglect.

The definition, in stages

AN ABUSIVE ACT OR FAILURE TO ACT?

THE REQUIRED IMPACT?

DOES AN EXCLUSION APPLY?

A “does not meet” vote at any stage ends the determination.

You may not attend. The person who made the allegation may not attend. Neither side’s lawyer may attend.

After the vote, the result goes to your commander and to you, with an explanation of the review process.

What a Met-Criteria Finding Does, and What It Does Not Do

A met-criteria finding is entered in the service’s FAP Central Registry and recorded in the Family Advocacy record. It is not placed in your medical record.

A MET-CRITERIA FINDING IS

Entered in the service’s FAP Central Registry · recorded in the Family Advocacy record

IT IS NOT

Placed in your medical record · a criminal conviction · a basis, by itself, for administrative or disciplinary action

It is not a criminal conviction. The committee is not a disciplinary proceeding under the UCMJ, and the UCMJ’s due process protections do not apply to it.

That cuts both ways. You do not get the protections of a court martial. But a commander may not take administrative or disciplinary action against you based solely on the committee’s finding. Command action needs its own basis, and that is where the defense goes to work.

In practice, a met-criteria finding can prompt command action: a GOMOR or other reprimand, adverse counseling, nonjudicial punishment or an administrative separation. Those are separate decisions, and each can be answered. Information presented to the committee can also be used as evidence in a disciplinary proceeding if it meets the normal legal requirements, and a commander deciding the initial disposition of an offense may consider it.

Be Careful What You Tell Family Advocacy

The intake feels like counseling. The provider may be kind. But the provider’s job includes assessing risk and making recommendations to your commander, and what you say can reach the case staff meeting and the committee.

Conversations with Family Advocacy do not carry the same protection as a conversation with your defense counsel. If information you give reaches the committee, it can become evidence in a disciplinary proceeding when it otherwise meets the legal requirements.

So talk to counsel before you talk about the incident. And never give a false account to anyone.

A Recantation Does Not End It

Spouses take allegations back all the time. The relationship cools off. The money gets tight. The kids miss their parent.

Under DoD rules, a recantation alone may not be used to conclude that abuse did not occur. It matters. It is not the end of the case. For more, read Can My Spouse Drop the Domestic Violence Case?

If the Committee Finds Met Criteria

You can ask for reconsideration under your service’s procedure. The notice of the determination explains the review process, and the details come from service rules: Army Regulation 608-18 for the Army, the OPNAVINST 1752.2 series for the Navy, MCO 1754.11 for the Marine Corps, and DAFI 40-301 for the Air Force and Space Force.

Reconsideration · service rules

ARMY

AR 608-18

NAVY

OPNAVINST 1752.2

MARINE CORPS

MCO 1754.11

AIR FORCE AND SPACE FORCE

DAFI 40-301

Then deal with what the finding sets in motion. If command moves toward a reprimand, adverse counseling or a separation, the response has to address the evidence, not just the finding. The committee voted on a more-likely-than-not standard. Command still has to decide for itself.

And keep the criminal case in view. A met-criteria finding does not mean charges are coming, and a did-not-meet finding does not mean they are not.

Not Every Family Advocacy Case Is the Right Fit for This Firm

Not every Family Advocacy referral needs a civilian trial firm.

If the case is limited to a FAP referral, with no investigation behind it and no command action on the horizon, you may not need us.

But if the Family Advocacy case is running beside a CID, NCIS or OSI investigation, a special trial counsel review, a protective order, a GOMOR or a separation, you are in a different fight. The committee vote, the command decision and the criminal case feed one another.

That is the kind of case this firm is built for. We will tell you which one you have.

Get Bilecki Into the Fight

If you are facing a Family Advocacy review or a met-criteria finding, do not wait for the committee to vote. Do not wait for command to act on the result.

Reach out to us and we will give you a free defense strategy session. It does not matter where you are stationed in the world. If you are ready to fight, then we are ready to fly in and fight like hell on your behalf.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Family Advocacy Program

What is the Family Advocacy Program?

The Family Advocacy Program (FAP) is the Department of Defense program that responds to reported domestic abuse and child abuse in military families. It provides assessment, safety planning and treatment, and its Incident Determination Committee decides whether a reported incident meets the DoD definition of abuse.

What does “met criteria” mean in a Family Advocacy case?

It means a majority of the Incident Determination Committee found it more likely than not that the incident meets the DoD definition of abuse. The incident is then entered in the service’s FAP Central Registry. It is not a criminal conviction.

Can I attend the Incident Determination Committee or bring a lawyer?

No. The accused service member, the person who made the allegation and their attorneys may not attend. Your commander may attend and vote on your incident, which is why the information your commander has before the meeting matters.

Can I appeal a Family Advocacy finding?

You can request reconsideration under your service’s procedure, and the notice of the determination explains the review process. Any command action that follows the finding, such as a reprimand or a separation, can also be answered on its own terms.

Can my commander punish me because Family Advocacy found met criteria?

Not based solely on the finding. A commander may not take administrative or disciplinary action based solely on the committee’s determination, but may act on independent legal or other appropriate advice. That is why the defense focuses on the evidence behind any command action.

Should I talk to Family Advocacy?

Talk to defense counsel first. What you tell Family Advocacy can reach your command and the committee, and it does not carry the same protection as a conversation with your lawyer. Refusing the assessment is reported too, so decide with counsel how to respond.

Is Family Advocacy the same as a CID, NCIS or OSI investigation?

No. Family Advocacy is a clinical and administrative process, and the military criminal investigative organizations handle criminal investigations. The two often run at the same time, certain allegations must be reported to investigators immediately, and information can move between them.

Will a met-criteria finding stay on my record?

It is entered in the service’s FAP Central Registry and recorded in the Family Advocacy record, not in your medical record. How long it is kept and who can see it depend on DoD and service rules.

If you are facing a Family Advocacy review or an Incident Determination Committee finding, contact Bilecki Law Group for a free case evaluation.

To talk with our firm about a Family Advocacy case, call 813-669-3500 or book a free consultation.

Get Free Case Evaluation

Call 813-669-3500Book your case review